Should the left participate in the Greens or Labour? A debate between James McAsh and Peter McColl

We have published a four-part written debate on whether the left should participate in Labour or the Green Party. James McAsh, a member of the London Young Labour Executive Committee, argues for Labour and Peter McColl Scottish Green Party Parliamentary Candidate for Edinburgh East, argues for the Greens.

Part 1 outlined McAsh’s argument for the Labour Party.

Part 2 gave McColl’s pro-Green position.

Part 3, by McAsh, offered a rebuttal to McColl. 

Part 4 returned to McColl. 

Part 5 offered a further critique of McAsh’s position from Jen Izaakson and Ross Speer